The no-action letter is the primary to expressly allow token switch off-platform to non-users and conversion to fiat foreign money by token holders.
As crypto costs surge, we discover ourselves within the midst of one other crypto wave. Given the unrelenting circulation of stories that accompanies such durations, it could have been straightforward to overlook that the SEC workers just lately granted no-action aid to a different Ethereum-based token, VCOIN.
In solely its third no-action letter thus far for digital tokens, the SEC cleared the best way for the software program growth firm IMVU, Inc.to promote VCOIN, an ERC-20 token, as a transferable non-security to its international platform customers. In its incoming letter, IMVU acknowledged that it operates “one of many largest on-line three-dimensional avatar-based social communities on the earth” with “over 7 million month-to-month energetic customers from greater than 140 international locations” and “a user-generated digital items catalog of greater than 40 million objects.” In the identical letter, IMVU sought steerage from the SEC as as to whether its providing of VCOIN would require registration underneath Part 5 of the Securities Act and Part 12(g) of the Trade Act.
A Easy Resolution for a Easy Truth Sample?
The SEC workers issued an affirmative response to IMVU’s request on November 19, 2020, with a set of stipulations upon which the no-action place is contingent. Particularly, the SEC set forth eight situations to which IMVU should adhere to ensure that VCOINs, as proposed, to take care of non-security standing. For essentially the most half, the stipulations mirror the identical Howey-driven necessities enumerated by the SEC in its no-action aid granted to Pocketful of Quarters, Inc. (PoQ) in July 2019 (mentioned on this weblog post) and TurnKey Jet, Inc. (TKJ) in April 2019 (mentioned on this weblog post). These stipulations embody that VCOIN will (i) be limitless in provide and offered at a hard and fast value, with no prospect of appreciation ensuing from IMVU’s efforts; (ii) be instantly usable for the supposed consumptive (and never speculative) objective on a totally functioning platform; (iii) have restrictions on purchases, conversions, transfers, and secondary market buying and selling; and (iv) preserve anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) precautions in accordance with Financial institution Secrecy Act and AML laws.
In an period when the cool children of crypto are creating ever extra unique and mind-bending monetary devices within the decentralized finance house, one might be forgiven for viewing the SEC’s approval of a stablecoin with restricted transferability as being lower than earth-shattering. Nonetheless, there’s worth in understanding the VCOIN mannequin, particularly as in comparison with the TKJ and PoQ fashions. On the very least, such an train permits us to know the SEC’s trajectory on this space.
Collectively, the three initiatives inform a narrative of regulators which are step by step changing into extra permissive. Recall, TKJ described its network as a “non-public, permissioned, centralized blockchain community and sensible contract infrastructure operated by TKJ.” Then got here the PoQ token, which was issued on Ethereum, a public blockchain community. In contrast to the TKJ and PoQ fashions, the VCOIN no-action aid is the primary to allow customers to switch a token exterior of its closed platform to non-users and for any token holder to have the ability to trade the token for fiat foreign money from the token issuer — IMVU on this case.
IMVU’s incoming letter reviews that IMVU’s digital world has over 75,000 “Creators and Service Suppliers” that present digital items and companies for IMVU’s customers. The Creators and Service Suppliers rent non-users (equivalent to programmers, designers, influencers, and so forth.) “to construct, market, or present help associated to the digital items and companies they provide” in IMVU’s digital world. The introduction of VCOIN permits producers to extract real-world worth in return for his or her exercise in IMVU’s digital financial system.
From the TKJ token to VCOIN, we see an evolution from a extremely restricted token issued on a non-public and centralized blockchain and aimed toward a slim person base (non-public jet charters) to a public blockchain token for a platform with 7 million customers which are in a position to switch the token off-platform to non-users, albeit with some fee-based disincentives to discourage hypothesis. We sit up for seeing how this development holds up in future no-action letters.
Digital World Progress, Actual World Stagnation
Given the rising record of regulatory questions raised by the crypto house, the necessity for a complete digital asset framework has change into extra urgent. As broadly predicted, regulatory uncertainty within the US has allowed different nations extra hospitable to digital asset innovation to start to tug forward in a know-how that some argue shall be as transformative because the web.
This text is made obtainable by Latham & Watkins for academic functions solely in addition to to offer you common info and a common understanding of the regulation, to not present particular authorized recommendation. Your receipt of this communication alone creates no lawyer shopper relationship between you and Latham & Watkins. Any content material of this text shouldn’t be used as an alternative to competent authorized recommendation from a licensed skilled lawyer in your jurisdiction.